top of page

Are Trump's Executive Orders Democratically Valid in the Face of a Hostile Congress?

Ashlie Davies
2 hours ago
4 min read

Throughout the first half of Trump's second term, there was much discussion about the impotency of Congress, supposing that it was acting as an extension of the executive rather than a distinct branch of government. In the wake of the 2026 midterm elections, in which the Democrats achieved generational victories with over 250 House seats and a commanding Senate majority, this impotency will likely not continue. The last time Congress saw such lopsided opposition majorities was more than thirty years ago, when bipartisanship was much stronger and ideological lines more blurred. It is expected, then, that President Trump will rely on executive orders to continue to push his policy agenda, in contravention of the rejection of his party in the midterms.


Put simply, an executive order is a unilateral, binding order issued by the President which manages how the federal government acts and organizes. This power is not explicitly granted in the Constitution but has been implicitly found in the powers and duties granted in Article II. Specifically, Article II Section 1 states that "The executive Power shall be vested in a President" and Section 3 states that "he shall take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed." These have been interpreted by Presidents, Congress and the Supreme Court as empowering the President to direct the operations of the federal government through the mechanism of executive orders.


Unfortunately, this power is ill-defined in scope and process, stemming from Article II's ambiguity and is, consequently, deeply controversial. Presidents have historically relied on them to push unilateral action without earning approval from Congress, drawing claims of undemocratic usurpation from alternating sides of the aisle. Such controversy intensifies when a President faces a hostile Congress and low approval ratings, as President Trump currently does. A common argument from the opposition following a midterm victory is that people have voted for bipartisanship and that the President should then cooperate with the new legislature. Such an argument is clearly in contrast to ideas about executive autonomy, a principle cherished by President Trump.


Above the fray of partisanship, the more foundational clash is where the democratic validity of executive orders arises: is it the Constitution, because it grants the President exclusive executive power ('executive autonomy'), or a continuous democratic mandate, because an electorally successful President has been imbued with a mandate to act unilaterally ('legislative legitimacy')?


It's important to clarify that few legitimacy proponents would deny the constitutionality of the power itself; such a claim isn't found in conventional political discussion. Instead, their position identifies a conflict between the President's discretion over executive orders and the lack of a continuous democratic mandate to act unilaterally, which they claim vanishes with an opposing Congress. If voters have soundly rejected the incumbent party and the President, albeit indirectly, then the mandate that provides justification for unilateral executive action is diminished and therefore should be used cautiously and reservedly.


A counterargument from the executive autonomy camp supposes that as the President is not officially 'on the ballot' in the midterms, any results cannot strictly be read as a repudiation of that President's original electoral mandate to act unilaterally. After all, people knowingly vote for and entrust power to Presidents for four-year terms, changing one's mind in the intervening time doesn't necessarily mean that power should be withdrawn. However, this argument mostly just plays with semantics; no serious political commentator would claim that Presidential performance and midterm results are independent of one another, considering poor Presidential approval is strongly correlated with midterm losses. Therefore, it's disingenuous to detach the two when it comes to checking Presidential power; the concept of a second term ‘lame duck’ President - whose political capital diminishes as their tenure winds down - relies on such a link.


Another counterargument focuses on a strictly originalist and/or textualist interpretation of the Constitution: the President is entrusted with executive power for a four-year term and so has an unlimited right to use it, within the restrictions of the Constitution, until their term expires. At this point, the differences between the autonomy and legitimacy positions are axiomatic and foundational (i.e. should we follow the 'spirit' or 'text' of the law). Regardless, such an overwhelmingly textualist reading of the Constitution is disingenuous and inconsistent; a strict reading would not support the modern concept of an executive order in the first place, as their modern usage brushes against the intention of the founding fathers to constrain executive power. Article II's ambiguity further clouds what exactly the power was intended for: was it even imagined that they would become a central Presidential power? The first executive order was President Washington merely directing his officers to inform him of the United States’ affairs, one of only eight he would issue. In fact, the first forty years of the Presidency saw only eighteen executive orders; the last forty have seen nearly 2000. Considering this, the originalist and/or textualist argument is misinformed at best and constitutional vaguebooking at worst.


The possibility of a mid-term change in Congressional control exists as an in-built check on executive autonomy beyond the mere fluctuations in seats.


It's a more foundational rejection of unilateral executive action, especially under this administration. Trump’s future executive orders, therefore, hold little democratic validity, with proponents of legislative legitimacy holding the more valid interpretation.


On a more practical level, governing primarily through executive orders rather than legislative consent is simply tough and riddled with legal challenges. Look at the firestorm around President Obama’s 2014 immigration reform orders, in which the Republican Congress repeatedly tried to strip various immigration programs of their funding. In the end, the order was halted following legal challenges from Republican-led states and a deadlocked 2016 Supreme Court. It is no stretch of the imagination to foresee similar events playing out with Trump and the incoming Congress, especially since he has already shown himself to be a President willing to test Congressional power. Ultimately, only time will tell whether he continues pushing executive authority or pivots toward legislative compromise, but don't hold your breath.


By: Ashlie Davies

Comments


WARWICK'S STUDENT POLITICS MAGAZINE

Perspectives is Warwick Politics Society's magazine publication giving Warwick students the best chance to have their political opinions heard.

  • White Facebook Icon
  • White Instagram Icon
  • LinkedIn
Warwick Politics Society Logo February 2
bottom of page