top of page

Trump, Putin and Xi meet on Thursday: here's what you need to know

Vivienne Ponsford
3 hours ago
5 min read

By Vivienne Ponsford



Trump, Xi and Putin meet on Thursday. Here’s what you need to know.

 

On Thursday 19 November, Xi Jinping, Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin will meet in Shenzhen on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit. It will be the first time the three leaders have met together. The meeting has generated a flood of commentary, from comparisons with the 1945 Yalta Conference to predictions that it will amount to little more than a photo opportunity. This raises the question: what is actually at stake?


China’s foreign ministry said on Monday that the leaders plan an ‘in-depth exchange of views on safeguarding world peace and enabling strategic stability in major-country relations’. The wording is deliberately broad, and the three leaders arrive with sharply different priorities.

 

What is APEC?

 

Founded in 1989, APEC is a forum of 21 economies, including the US and Russia, whose members account for about 62 per cent of global GDP and roughly half of global trade. This is China’s third time hosting the summit. As host, Beijing controls the setting, the schedule and, crucially, the choreography of Thursday’s meeting.

 

Why does China matter?

 

Like his predecessors, Xi Jinping leads China’s Communist Party, state and military, but he is widely regarded as China’s most powerful leader since its first leader, Mao Zedong. In 2018, China’s parliament scrapped the two-term limit on the presidency that Deng Xiaoping had introduced to prevent a return to Mao-style one-man rule. In 2022, Xi broke the convention that party leaders step down after two terms, and he is widely expected to begin a fourth term at the party congress in 2027.

 

China’s significance, however, extends well beyond its leader. With the world’s largest population after India, the second-largest economy and growing technological and military capabilities, China is widely regarded as the United States’ principal rival. Therefore, any meeting that places Xi between the leaders of the US and Russia is as much about status as it is about substance.

 

What each leader wants 

 

Unsurprisingly, the three leaders are each coming to the table with their own agenda. As Sun Chenghao, a fellow with Tsinghua University’s Centre for International Security and Strategy, put it, ‘the expectations of the three sides are currently misaligned’. 

 

Trump wants to talk about nuclear arms control, something Beijing has long resisted, arguing that the US and Russia, with far larger arsenals, should negotiate directly. On Monday, Trump also said that they would discuss Iran and his ‘favourite subject’, Ukraine. Yet only days earlier, a senior US official told Reuters that Trump was not expected to raise Ukraine at all, a sign of how unsettled the agenda remains. 


 This is China’s third time hosting the summit. As host, Beijing controls the setting, the schedule and, crucially, the choreography of Thursday’s meeting.

Putin also wants to talk about Ukraine, but a person familiar with Russia’s thinking told the Financial Times that Moscow did not expect substantive talks on the war during the summit. For Russia, the image may matter more than the agenda. Danny Russel, a former senior US State Department official, told AP that Putin has the most to gain from the meeting, describing it as a potential ‘diplomatic coup’ for Moscow.

 

So, what does China get out of it? Beijing wants to avoid taking sides in the conflicts in Ukraine and Iran, and according to the same FT source, it has little appetite for leading peace efforts. Instead, Da Wei, a professor at Tsinghua University, argued that China would use the meeting to demonstrate its diplomatic weight and Xi’s statesmanship. Sun Chenghao made a similar point: hosting the meeting could show China’s ability to act as a bridge between the major powers, while signalling that its partnership with Russia and its engagement with the US can advance side by side.

 

Why now?

 

After the ‘blue wave’ of 3 November, in which the Democrats won control of both the House and the Senate, Trump returns to the world stage weakened at home. Analysts suggest he is now seeking a diplomatic win abroad. However, the new Congress is warier of Russia and China than Trump is, which may limit how many of his deals stick.

 

Trade adds further pressure. The US-China trade truce, which keeps tariffs and the flow of rare earths stable, was extended in September and now expires on 10 January. That makes Shenzhen one of the last chances for the two leaders to agree on what comes next.

 

The Yalta comparison 

 

The meeting has drawn repeated comparisons with the Yalta conference of 1945 when Churchill, Roosevelt and Stalin met to shape the post-war world. Yalta is bitterly remembered in Eastern Europe as a great-power carve-up that handed Moscow a ‘sphere of influence’ at its neighbours’ expense. Today, there are fears in Kyiv that Putin could persuade the US and China to back a settlement that favours Russia’s view of the war.

 

Both Moscow and Beijing reject the parallel. Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said  Russia and China stand for a ‘multi-polar world order’ in which no decisions are imposed on other nations, while Beijing would ‘definitely oppose’ any attempt to frame the meeting as a new Yalta. The context is also different. Yalta took place in the midst of a world war that was remaking the world order, not on the sidelines of a trade summit.

 

What to expect

 

Expectations are low, including in Washington. A senior US official told Reuters, ‘we do not expect to get to any kind of agreement’, describing the meeting as the start of a conversation. Craig Singleton, senior director of the China program at the Foundation for Defence of Democracies, went further, suggesting it may amount to little more than a photo opportunity, and warning that such moments have ‘diminishing diplomatic returns'. 


Others see room for modest progress. Sun Chenghao expects a ‘limited consensus’, such as reaffirming the prevention of nuclear war, maintaining crisis communication, and scheduling follow-up talks between experts. The South China Morning Post has also reported that the meeting could produce a commitment to control the use of artificial intelligence in nuclear arsenals. 

 

On Thursday, there are five things to watch:

 

A joint statement on whether the three leaders agree on any shared language, particularly on nuclear arms or AI. For Ukraine, whether the war is discussed, given the mixed signals from Washington and Moscow. Any change in how Trump or Xi describe Taiwan’s status. Whether Trump presses Xi and Putin on the war with Iran, on China’s financial ties to Tehran and on trade, and whether Trump and Xi use their separate meeting to extend the truce beyond 10 January.

 

Whatever the outcome of the meeting, the image of the three leaders side by side will send a message of its own, and the world will be reading it closely.


Image: The White House / Wikimedia Commons



 

 

Comments


WARWICK'S STUDENT POLITICS MAGAZINE

Perspectives is Warwick Politics Society's magazine publication giving Warwick students the best chance to have their political opinions heard.

  • White Facebook Icon
  • White Instagram Icon
  • LinkedIn
Warwick Politics Society Logo February 2
bottom of page